Island Life: Shelter Island
An alternative to Hamptons glitz.
By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Named for the shelter it provided Quakers during their 17th-century persecution in New England, you'll find a different kind of refuge today--as a less kempt, more charming alternative to the social whirl of the nearby Hamptons.
Yes, there's a pricey Andre Balazs hotel, but that's the last reason to visit this idyll of windswept shores tucked between the twin forks of eastern Long Island. Go for a day to hike the Mashomack Preserve -- 2,039 acres of tidal creeks, oak woodlands, fields, and marshes -- or stay the weekend at the low-key La Maison Blanche, where guests are welcome to borrow the inn's bikes. Pack a few stellar pastries from the attached bakery and take a ride to the wood-framed Union Chapel in the Grove, the island's oldest building. Or just hang out poolside with a book.