11 Gay, German Movies From 1924-2004


By Andrew Belonsky

German movies from the Weimer Republic, East Berlin, and the 21st Century.

Germany has been churning out gay hits for nearly a century. Here, 11 gay movies, from the dramatic to the comedic, from the absurd to the touching, from the Weimer Republic to unified Berlin, straight out of Germany.

1. Michael ("Michael"), 1924: Based on Herman Bang's 1902 novel, Mikaël, and directed by legendary silent movie filmmaker Carl Theodor Dreyer, this Weimer Republic-era picture, also called Mikaël, Chained: The Story of the Third Sex, ruffled a few feathers for its frank, sympathetic portrayal of a painter who falls for one of his male models, but mostly the critics were either too shy to discuss it or it went over their heads.

2. Die Büchse der Pandora ("Pandora's Box"), 1929: Actress Alice Roberts reportedly wasn't keen on playing tuxedo-wearing lesbian Countess Augusta Geschwitz in this pre-talkie feature, but she did anyway, pulling off the role of a woman lusting after Louise Brooks's Lulu, a woman on her way toward the end of her wits, and Jack the Ripper's blade.

3. Mädchen in Uniform ("Girls in Uniform"), 1931: While homosexuality was simply alluded to in the aforementioned flicks, it was on full display in Mädchen in Uniform, the tale of a boarding school girl who falls for her teacher. The movie, based on Christa Winsloe's play Gestern und heute, was so influential that it was remade in 1958. It was such a big deal in the US when it came out that there was an immediate Broadway adaptation, and Irving Thalberg asked for more lesbian undertones to be added to the script for Queen Christina, starring Garbo.

4. Anders als du und Ich ("Different From You and Me"), 1957: Not to be confused with the similarly gay 1919 movie Anders als die Andern ("Different from the Others"), this mid-20th Century narrative revolves around rich kid Klaus's affair with a lower-class peer named Manfred. Drama ensues. And drama also ensued when the picture came out — not only were conservatives displeased with the gay content, early gay activists were livid over an ending in which, spoiler alert, Klaus is "cured" of his homosexuality. This clip shows Klaus mooning over his unrequited love. The entire movie, subtitles and all, is also available at YouTube.

5. Nicht der Homosexuelle ist pervers, sondern die Situation, in der er lebt ("It Is Not The Homosexual Who Is Perverse, But The Society In Which He Lives"), 1971: Perhaps one of the most controversial gay features ever to come out of Germany, or anywhere else, this mouthful of a movie and its portrayal of gay men as shallow, fashion-obsessed, limp wristed weaklings created such a stir that the videotaped criticisms from gay activists constitute their own short. It's called "Audience Response to It's not the Homosexual…"

See clips from films from 1975 to 2004 on the following page.