What a difference a good hair day makes. Finn Wittrock, Ryan Murphy's favorite eye candy on American Horror Story, didn't hit a home run in the series' Hotel season -- sorry, the eyeliner and mullet combo wasn't really doing it for us. But once Wittrock cleans up, he looks like everything a perfect leading man should be. On Sunday, at the 21st Critics' Choice Awards, the actor donned a tailored midnight blue tuxedo with a contrasting shawl lapel, and simply accessorized it with a silk bow tie. Take note, gents: Less is more.