Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Queer throuple on SLOMW: OC is sparking a conversation about homophobia in Mormonism

Will Aspyn Ovard's throuple lead to needed conversations about LGBTQ+ rights and Mormonism on Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County? Let's discuss.

The throuple in Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County
Ashley Rose/Disney

This story originally appeared on Them.

From episode one, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County has branded itself as the more progressive spin-off of the popular Hulu reality television show about Mormon wives balancing full-time influencing with their religious values.

Although Layla Taylor, one of the original cast members of Mormon Wives, came out as bisexual earlier this year, SLOMW fans had yet to see any of the wives grapple with queerness and their Mormon upbringing on screen — that is, until the Southern California-set franchise newcomer heavily featured a queer throuple.


Aspyn Ovard, one of the cast members of the new series, is openly in a throuple with Bri and Billy Davis, a woman and a man who are married to each other. Coming from a small town in southern Utah that she describes as a Mormon “bubble,” Ovard got married at 19 to her high-school sweetheart. Navigating co-parenting following her divorce is a central conflict throughout the show’s first season.

But Ovard’s throuple also frequently becomes fodder for group conversation throughout the first season of the new series, especially given Mormonism’s history with polygamy, the practice of a man having multiple wives. The main branch of the Mormon Church moved to end the practice of polygamy in 1890. As her fellow castmates confuse polyamory with polygamy, Ovard repeatedly has to clarify the difference, much to her chagrin.

Beyond her relationship, Ovard’s queerness serves as an emblematic plot point to the show’s defining message: How do all these women with a connection to the Mormon Church navigate the modern world while practicing their faith? And do their personal views conflict with their faith?

One of the most explosive moments of the series comes after mounting tension between Aspyn and McCall DaPron comes to a head. Aspyn says that she feels that McCall, perhaps the spin-off’s most devoutly Mormon cast member, is homophobic and accuses her of refusing to to say that she supports LGBTQ+ rights. McCall fires back that she has plenty of gay friends, isn’t homophobic, and feels Aspyn is actually being discriminatory about her religion. While the pair attempt to squash their conflict during an outing to a Las Vegas gay bar, Aspyn reiterates she feels McCall simply being in the presence of queer people isn’t enough to prove her support.

“There is just so much homophobia within the Mormon church, so it’s hard for me to believe they can be Mormon and still supportive of gay rights,” Aspyn told Elite Daily in reference to McCall and castmate Jordan McClanahan. “I know they are supportive of my relationship, but it’s bigger than that. I want my friends to be aligned with me politically, and to care about gay rights and all these other things that really matter to me.”

Below, Them editor-in-chief (and ex-Mormon) Samantha Allen and I unpack the nuances, conflicts, and tensions surrounding queerness in this season of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County. — Quispe López

Quispe López: Samantha, SLOMW: OC is clearly a rich tapestry of ongoing tensions between new-age Mormons and the old teachings of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. What do you make of homophobia becoming a central conflict point this season?

Samantha Allen: Full disclosure, all of my cards on the table — but not face cards, because those are sinful! — I’m an ex-Mormon who formally left the church in 2008. Like, I had to write a letter asking for my name to be removed from the records and everything.

Later that year, I watched the Mormon Church’s advocacy for California’s anti-gay marriage ballot propositiondrive a wedge through the hearts of my more progressive friends who were hoping they could change the faith from within. And I felt for them, but I also knew they were fighting a long battle.

Here’s the thing: All the Mormon Church has technically done on gay issues is turn down the temperature on some of the more overt fire-and-brimstone homophobia. Doctrinally, same-sex relationships are still completely verboten.

The only shift has been a change from “being gay is a sin” in the 1970s and 1980s to, in more recent decades, “you can be a gay person in the faith so long as you are completely celibate and comfortable being a second-class member.”

So when McCall appears uncomfortable with Aspyn, I get why! If you actually believe in Mormonism, literally, and as the leadership defines it, you should not be OK with what they’re doing. And to me, that’s one of the most fascinating things about SLOMW having such a huge, non-Mormon audience: A lot of outsiders don’t really get how brittle and inelastic the Mormon Church can be on an organizational level. I do wonder sometimes if reality TV Mormonism gives an inflated impression of how viable it is to be a “cultural Mormon” compared to the practical reality of the faith.As a never-Mormon, how much of that comes across to you when you watch this season?

Quispe: That definitely seemed to be the line of thinking they were trying to explore through the homophobia conflict. While I didn’t grow up Mormon, I did grow up Catholic and there is certainly a similar dynamic called “cafeteria Catholicism” where you’re able to pick and choose what parts of the faith and culture you want to engage with. Of course, cafeteria Catholicism is looked down upon by devout Catholics — similarly to the attitude we might see among McCall and other “molly Mormons” on the SLOMW cast — but it is something that exists and is recognized as a phenomenon.

In my Catholic yet non-Mormon perspective, it seems like the project of SLOMW — especially with regards to conversations on queerness, drinking, and other things that are forbidden by the church — is simply to establish that “cafeteria Mormonism” or cultural Mormonism” exists.

Speaking of this dynamic, I’m curious how you feel about McCall’s criticism of Aspyn participating in the show at all as someone who disapproves of the Mormon Church’s positions, especially given that the show is about “Mormon wives.” Do you think the perspective Aspyn brings is valuable to the project of the show? Do you think it’s actively trying to make Mormonism “more progressive”?

Samantha: I mean, I am fascinated by the throuple! If anything, I want 500% more Aspyn. I think SLOMW certainly seems to have a mission of bucking Mormon stereotypes, and naturally, that’s going to mean showcasing people who live more progressively than the vast majority of practicing members live — or at least claim to live. We all know about soaking by now!

Granted, I’ve been out of the Mormon game for a while now, but my impression from afar is that the culture on the ground is changing much faster than the leadership is changing hands. The current president of the faith, whom Mormons believe speaks for God as a prophet, is 94 years old! And the church’s core, underlying stance on gay issues really hasn’t changed across his entire lifetime. Think about everything that’s happened in that near-century, from the repeal of sodomy laws to the legalization of same-sex marriage to mainstream awareness of trans people. Of course younger Mormons are going to have a somewhat more liberal perspective on things, but their faith is a literal gerontocracy. I know a similar dynamic has played out within Catholics: a lot of change among the lay membership, but much more gradual shifts at the top.

If I had to speculate, McCall may be one of those members who feels like she has to toe the party line or else she’s committing heresy. People feel that pressure not just socially, but inside their own minds. But I think there are a lot of Mormons — maybe including McCall, who knows? — who would feel tremendous relief if the leadership legitimately changed its stance on LGBTQ+ issues. When I was Mormon, that’s how many people described waiting for the 1978 lifting of the church’s ban on Black men in the priesthood: They told me they were culturally ready for it to happen, but just waiting for the rubber stamp from the prophet. Even then, it took the church until 2013 to even gesture toward the role racism played in that ban. So again, a long battle.

Anyway, that’s a lot of inside baseball, but I think what makes SLOMW so fascinating is that it just insistently inhabits that kind of cognitive dissonance. I’ve met Mormons who are like, “I drink coffee and I don’t believe in God and I go to church every Sunday.” Internally I’m like, huh?, but if those people want to call themselves Mormons, that’s the church’s problem to sort out!

Do you think the show is changing the cultural perception of Mormonism? I worry sometimes about people not realizing that, on an institutional level, the organization is still causing a lot of trauma for LGBTQ+ people who feel beholden to the doctrine, but maybe people are more aware of that than I think…

Quispe: To me, the show reads as an active attempt to change cultural perceptions of Mormons and speak to those differences in perspective among members. The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City does this as well. The general vibe of all these reality TV shows is, “Mormons, they’re just like the rest of us!”

But while it’s interesting to see the diversity of opinion among individual Mormons, I do worry that any show highlighting a version of Christianity whose leadership actively is doing harm to LGBTQ+ people might sanitize what’s happening structurally. Like you said, even if individual Mormons are supportive of LGBTQ+ people, it doesn’t mean the LDS Church itself isn’t doing harm. On a deeply serious note, look at the statistics for LGBTQ+ youth mental health in Utah. Aspyn seems to happily be in a queer throuple, but even she seems to face all sorts of social rejection.

That said, I’m curious how the conversations had on these shows might be used as a driver of change within the membership, especially if everyday Mormons watching SLOMW feel like it gives them permission to express support for LGBTQ+ people. Maybe this is overly optimistic as someone who didn't grow up in the LDS Church, but do you think reality shows like SLOMW could lead to positive change?

Samantha: Oh, God. I’m trying to imagine myself in the active Mormon mindset again! If I’m a true believer, I’m weighing the fact that the church has functionally called SLOMW and other Mormon reality TV fare “gross misrepresentations that are in poor taste and have real-life consequences for people of faith.” That’s a pretty stern message for an organization that didn’t even get that riled up about The Book of Mormon musical, comparatively speaking.

But if I’m an edge case or a doubter, maybe these shows help? I have to imagine many, if not most, Mormons are watching these wives do their thing anyway. And then I think about how many millions of closeted bisexual Mormon women there must be trapped in strictly heterosexual marriages! If I’m in their shoes, watching Aspyn and Bri kiss every chance they get might awaken something in me.

Will they help? Maybe we can pray they will?

Quispe: We can certainly hope that, if anything, this iteration of SLOMW leads to a wave of bisexual Mormon awakenings.

Get the best of what’s queer. Sign up for Them’s newsletters.

FROM OUR SPONSORS