Prices vary, Jenisicecreams.com
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams, a small ice cream chain in Columbus, Oh., is something of a Christmas miracle. Take, for example, their seasonal Buttercup Pumpkin & Amaretti Cookies, for which heirloom pumpkins are roasted and blended with cream and crumbled Italian cookies. Or, if you prefer, long-time favorite flave, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, which is salty, sweet, and wholly delicious. Who else does that? And why Columbus? Who knows? Who cares? Order as many or as few as you want, or have Jeni select nine tubs for $90. You're worth it.