Some of the best movies by the best gay filmmakers are not about gay people. Think of the legends: Cocteau, Visconti, Almodovar elevated world cinema by extending their sensibilities to address the essence of the human condition as in
Orpheus, Bellissima, Senso, White Nights
; often by concentrating on universal experiences or a female lead character whose actions and emotions illuminate all relationships as in
Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown
. That's the model Richard Glatzer and Wash Westmoreland follow in
Julianne Moore plays linguistics professor Alice Howland, a 50-year-old married mother of three, who is diagnosed with Early-Onset Alzheimers Disease. How she suffers the loss of her thinking ("I am defined by my intellect, articulation, language") makes for a story of identifiable sorrow and tenderness. Glatzer and Westmoreland, partners who live together and have made collaborative films since 1994, think and feel outside the gay ghetto. Westmoreland, whose filmmaking apprenticeship includes several porn features, expands their repertoire.
's non-frivolous subject has personal significance for the duo (Glatzer was diagnosed with ALS in 2011) but the film is notable for the continually broadened scope of their filmmaking (beginning in 2006 with
which observed a teenage Latina's coming of age). Awareness of the larger world is also part of Glatzer and Westmoreland's humanity, their gay humanity, their artistry.
The essential subject matter of art does not change for gay artists. Alice's interactions with husband John (Alec Baldwin), son Tom (Hunter Parrish) and daughters Anna (Kate Bosworth) and Lydia (Kristen Stewart) have the requisite--and recognizable--tonal differences to make their varied personalities credible. Some scenes recall the familial insight of Thomas Bezucha's
The Family Stone
, another outside-the-gay-ghetto touchstone.
's best scenes, Glatzer and Westmoreland convey the value we place on our human functions and the complexity of family tensions. They casually and pointedly detail Alice's life habits: teaching, cooking, cleaning, speaking--everyday rituals that foreground and introduce mortality.
Westmoreland and Glatzer engage Alice's dilemma by showing what gay artists have learned from the AIDS crisis about humanity and mortality--from porn to profundity. The AIDS experience has taught the world compassion. That lesson is felt, despite the film's stylistic ordinariness, in Alice's conflicts with rebellious Lydia whose struggling acting career mirrors Alice's clinical struggle with self-expression. Moore and Stewart have complementary acting rhythms with Stewart showing intensely beautiful anger and remorse; she channels it into Lydia's performance of a scene from Chekhov's
and her own recitation of a speech from
Angels in America, Part II (Perestroika)
Playwright Tony Kushner wrote
Angels in America
as an attempt to exceed party politics and sexual politics through visionary poetry ("souls were rising, floating up like sky divers in reverse"). He implied that spirituality transcends sexuality and his effort is affirmed when Alice fumbles to describe the play's scope but says "scape." It's a good gaffe because the landscape of gay filmmaking needs precisely the expansion of storytelling territory as Glatzer and Westmoreland demonstrate. That's how
differs from gay filmmaker Todd Haynes' repugnant
(1994), in which Moore also played a heterosexual woman plagued by illness.
Haynes' inability to empathize except with pathological conditions is an artistic disability. It is the opposite of what Cocteau, Visconti and Almodovar have taught; opposite the broad humanity gay director Patrice Chereau showed in
which transferred AIDS crisis to a wider experience; opposite Robert Altman's great leap forward into female and gay consciousness in
Come Back to the 5 & Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean
Moore's Alice, struggling with "the art of losing," isn't a high camp virago like a drag version of Bette Davis in
or Susan Hayward in
; neither is she a non-camp drip like her role in Haynes' pseudo soap-opera Far From Heaven. Dealing with non-gay experience so sensitively, Glatzer and Westmoreland consider our spirituality.
awakens our human responses.
opens for a one-week awards qualifying run in New York City and Los Angeles on Dec. 5. Watch the trailer below: