Two Politicians Have Been Called On to Resign. Only One of Them Should

Eric Porterfield of West Virginia and Ilhan Omar of Minnesota: Only one should resign.

Eric Porterfield is a Republican member of the West Virginia House of Delegates, representing the state’s 27th district since January of this year. He’s also a mess. He’s managed to do such a bad job in office that, only five weeks into his term, people are calling on him to resign.

During a House committee meeting over a bill that would have prohibited cities in the state from passing non-discrimination protections for LGBTQ+ people, Porterfield began ranting about how “the LGBT is the most socialist group in this country.” He doubled down on his comments in subsequent interviews with The Charleston Gazette-Mail and local NBC affiliate WVVA by comparing “the LGBTQ” to the Ku Klux Klan, accusing us of committing “political terrorism,” and declaring us “a blight on this country and a blight in our communities.”

Perhaps most disturbing of all, he told WVVA journalist Rachel Anderson that if his son or daughter ever came out to him, he’d see if they “could swim.” Anderson pressed him to unpack what that meant, but Porterfield declined to do so. Eventually, he said, “I just wanna make sure they can swim,” but the troubling implication that he’d drown his kids if he found out they were gay rings loud and clear to anyone who cares to listen.

Republicans have denounced Porterfield, and state Democrats have called on him to resign for spouting such garbage, NBC News reports. He absolutely should. In five weeks, he’s shown himself to be unfit to serve the people in his district, especially those who are LGBTQ+. 

The response to Porterfield reminds me of what’s happening to Representative Ilhan Omar right now. Earlier this week, the congresswoman from Minnesota was accused of perpetuating anti-semitic tropes about Jewish people thanks to a fundamental misreading of some tweets she posted criticizing the cashflow between pro-Israel lobbyists and U.S. lawmakers. It was a “facile accusation,” writes journalist Noah Kulwin in Jewish Currents, that ignores how lobbying groups like AIPAC, which Omar called out by name, are “explicitly in the business of trading influence for money.”

Many Democrats have denounced Omar, including House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and President Donald Trump called for her resignation Tuesday, NPR reports. But unlike Porterfield, she shouldn’t resign. Omar never used her bully pulpit to terrorize a marginalized group. She never supported legislation that would further marginalize said marginalized group. Porterfield is trying to hurt people. Omar’s trying to hurt lobbying groups — which, for the record, are not people.

As a black, Muslim woman, Omar’s perceived wrongs will always be more visible than the actual wrongs committed by a white, Christian man like Porterfield, but that increased scrutiny doesn’t make these perceived wrongs any less fabricated. 

RELATED | Bolsonaro Plans to Remove LGBTQ+ Content from Brazilian Schools

From our Sponsors

READER COMMENTS ()